The Federation of Small Business Joins call to end LVCR VAT Avoidance Scheme

In a letter to the European Commission The Federation of Small Businesses has called upon EU officials to ensure that the UK Government brings to an end the abuse of Low Value Consignment Relief (LVCR). They join the Forum of Private Business (FPB), who has been campaigning on the issue since 2005.  LVCR stems from a little-known European Directive from 1983 and exempts goods from outside the EU below a certain threshold value (currently £18) from VAT. It was originally introduced to imports from The Channel Islands to reduce the time spent in Customs for perishable horticultural goods. However, for more than six years now, large UK retailers and indigenous Channel Island companies have been importing UK and EU products to the Channel Islands – outside the EU for VAT purposes – in order to retail them by mail order back to the UK free of VAT. Recently a senior HMRC official stated that “the relief and the special VAT position of the Channel Islands were never intended to be exploited in this way to supply goods VAT free to UK consumers” giving credence to the many complaints that The UK Government has had from UK business since the late 1990s that this practice is causing a major market distortion. Onshore retailers – initially of CDs and DVDs but more recently of various products from memory cards through to ink cartridges and gifts – who still have to charge VAT, have been suffering and going out of business, with entertainment retail being the most severely hit so far.

Now members of the Federation of Small Businesses who retail on the internet have been affected and in a strongly worded letter to the European Commission on behalf of its 200,000 members Mike Cherry, the FSB’s National Policy Chairman, highlights the abuse of LVCR in relation to its membership. In it he quotes a recent Eurostat report that reveals that 66% of individuals in the UK bought goods online in 2009. Mr Cherry describes the UK’s failure to protect VAT on internet retail as having  “grave consequences for fair competition on the internet within the EU market” and goes on to point out that  VAT is the “one tax that that has a direct effect on all small businesses and that the UK Authorities have failed in their duty to protect UK small business from the abuse of VAT through their  lax application of LVCR and acceptance of circular shipping which has resulted in onshore firms being unable to compete with large retailers, who have been able to set up operations in the Channel Islands and avoid VAT on goods intended for consumption within the EU/UK”  He concludes that “The distortion of competition caused by the UK Authorities’ inaction has created a severe imbalance forcing those who have to pay VAT out of business as they are unable to compete with those companies able to avoid VAT offshore” and he then calls on the commission to take firm action to ensure that the UK “ceases immediately from allowing such a flagrant tax avoidance scheme to continue”

Richard Allen, Spokesperson for RAVAS (Retailers Against VAT Avoidance Schemes), welcomed the FSB’s stance stating that “The FSB’s comment on this issue recognizes that the primary determinant of whether a business in one of the affected trades succeeds is now not the quality of its product, nor its status as a small or large, high-street or online business, but whether it can avoid charging VAT. An initially harmless European Tax relief is being exploited for a purpose totally contrary to its intentions.  We hope that the UK Government uses the budget to end this dishonest avoidance scheme once and for all.”

6 Comments

  1. Small businesses will still get punished by your local supermarkets. The likes of Tesco, Asda and Morrisons are selling CD, DVD and Blu-Rays at prices that small businesses buy them from wholesalers. To lower or abolish the LVCR will not make the problem that small businesses face. Unfortunately the ‘High Street’ is no more. The sooner this is realised the better.

    1. There are two initial blindingly obvious errors in this comment.

      1. It’s not about supermarkets or buying power – they would need shelf space the size of a small country to hold stock of everything that can be sold – smaller shops can easily co-exist either by specialising or by having a differentiating proposition – locality, access, service, experience, advice, environment – the list goes on.

      2. ITS NOT JUST ABOUT CDs and DVDs – LVCR is distorting the market in an increasing range of goods that will only get worse as time goes on. If you don’t stop the abuse now, when would be a good time, do you think? How many businesses and jobs should be sacrificed and how much VAT revenue lost?

      The “High Street” was still there last time I looked – it changes and adapts, as it always has, but it’s still there. And it could be more vibrant and thriving and full of variation and character if it can allowed to compete on a fair, even playing field with other retail environments, online and offline.

  2. This comment shows a poor knowledge of retail. Supermarkets only sell mainstream products and even then only get lower prices if they buy in bulk. The FSB protects the interests of some fairly large businesses so don’t portray them as a bunch of shop keepers. Most of the members of RAVAS retail online! In any case we are not just highlighting CDs and DVDs but any products sold on the internet. Trying to excuse an immoral offshore tax avoidance scheme by raising a non-related and badly informed supermarkets argument won’t save you. All we want is an even playing field on VAT in the UK/EU. We can fight our own corner on products and service. No problem.

  3. We sell a product that supermarkets don’t stock but are struggling to compete with CI based resellers. A tightening of the LVCR rules would be appreciated, thank-you very much.

  4. Population of Jersey = 87,000
    Population of Guernsey = 65,700

    Membership of FSB = 234,000 (x 2.4 to represent average family size = population of 561,600)

    Go figure….

  5. You can’t put a gloss on it or cover it up. LVCR is a blemish on society and a blot on the landscape.

Comments are closed.